Despite ‘repeal and replace’ vow, Republicans pull health care bill before vote

Pia Christensen

About Pia Christensen

Pia Christensen (@AHCJ_Pia) is the managing editor/online services for AHCJ. She manages the content and development of healthjournalism.org, coordinates AHCJ's social media efforts and edits and manages production of association guides, programs and newsletters.

Paul Ryan

Obamacare is the law of the land. … We’re going to be living with Obamacare for the foreseeable future.” – Paul Ryan

That was the speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives after pulling the GOP health care bill from consideration because it was clear there weren’t enough votes to pass it.

The Associated Press sums up the range of emotion after the decision was announced: After health care bill’s withdrawal, elation and anger. It also points out the “winners, losers and a few in between.”

On Facebook, Ezra Klein of Vox said that was not the headline he expected to see today.

Reporter Robert Costa of The Washington Post recounts the stunning phone call in which Trump told him the bill was no longer up for consideration.

Fox News says Trump is blaming Democrats for the bill’s failure, though Joanne Kenen, AHCJ’s core topic leader on health reform, points out in a tweet that “They didn’t need a single Democratic vote under the process they chose to follow.”

For a timeline of how events unfolded, see the live updates from Politico’s Brianna Ehley.

“Essential health benefits remain a big concern to Republicans so watch for some regulatory — though less sweeping — approach in the future under Sec. Tom Price,” Kenen said.

Trump and Ryan indicated that they were going to move on from trying to change the health care system, but there are some regulatory and other moves that could be made to change the Affordable Care Act.

Dan Diamond at Politico points out that the Trump administration has been reshaping the Affordable Care Act from his first day in office:

“The Trump administration has already begun to transform the health insurance market, wielding executive power to rewrite coverage rules, slash Obamacare’s marketing budget and signal an all-out assault on his predecessor’s health care law.”

For instance, in January, the Urban Institute  posted a research report, “Instead of ACA Repeal and Replace, Fix It,” which proposes some policies that could still “address critics’ concerns and also strengthen the law, expand coverage, improve affordability, increase market stability, and lower the high premiums that exist in some markets” (h/t to Liz Seegert)

Additional reading

One thought on “Despite ‘repeal and replace’ vow, Republicans pull health care bill before vote

  1. Eileen Beal

    Re:Trump and Ryan indicated that they were going to move on from trying to change the health care system, but there are some regulatory and other moves that could be made to change the Affordable Care Act.

    Anyone who believes these two guys have given up on gutting the ACA and plan to “move on” do not understand how they work….or why they wanted to gut it in the first place.

    Eileen Beal, Shaker Hts, OH.

Leave a Reply