Mental trauma is everywhere, panelists tell AHCJ members

Susan Heavey

About Susan Heavey

Susan Heavey, (@susanheavey) a Washington, D.C.-based journalist, is AHCJ’s topic leader on social determinants of health and curates related material at healthjournalism.org. She welcomes questions and suggestions on resources and tip sheets at determinants@healthjournalism.org.

Photo: Susan Heavey/AHCJAHCJ members in April attended a packed panel on covering mental trauma, from violence, child sexual abuse and other factors at Health Journalism 2016 in Cleveland. The speakers were Dr. Glenda Wrenn, director of behavioral health at Morehouse School of Medicine in Atlanta; Dr. Ewald Horwath, director of Case Western University’s Psychiatry Department; Kristine Buffington, a trained social worker based in Toledo, Ohio; and Kathleen Hackett, a sexual assault nurse examiner.

Photo: Susan Heavey/AHCJAHCJ members in April attended a packed panel on covering mental trauma at Health Journalism 2016 in Cleveland. The speakers were Dr. Glenda Wrenn, from Morehouse School of Medicine; Dr. Ewald Horwath, of Case Western University; Kristine Buffington, a social worker based in Toledo, Ohio; and Kathleen Hackett, a sexual assault nurse examiner.

A single tear is okay, but don’t cry.

Kathleen Hackett, a sexual assault nurse examiner, recently told AHCJ members that breaking down while listening to stories from victims can retraumatize them or even force them to emotionally shut down so as not to cause any one else pain.

“We have to be careful in our response,” said Hackett, who has more than 30 years of nursing experience and has worked with children in the hospital after their ordeal, adding that she never cries in front of her patients.

This was among several pieces of advice given during a panel on mental trauma at AHCJ’s annual conference last month in Cleveland. The session, led by independent journalist Katti Gray, broached a subject that, despite its importance, can be challenging to cover.

Trauma manifests itself in so many ways. Too frequently, society grapples with the symptoms of trauma that often lead people to be labeled “bad” instead of exploring, understanding and ultimately addressing the root causes of such behavior.

“Trauma is very common … throughout the lifespan,” said Dr. Ewald Horwath, who leads Case Western University’s Department of Psychiatry. “We’ve come to an understanding that especially recurrent traumatic experiences have profound effects on mental development and emotional development and on mental illness. And the path from trauma to mental illness is often quite complex, and the consequences can be devastating.”

For children who experience traumatic events, the impact can be everlasting.

Kristine Buffington, an Ohio social worker active in child trauma issues, said young people who go through such experiences can suffer biological changes that affect their behavior, development and executive function.

“When children go through chronic trauma again and again and again in their development, it can impact their entire childhood,” she said.

Trauma can damage cells, increase the hormone cortisol, and prevent children from forming attachments, Buffington said. Add the emotional response, and “a cascade” of problems can ensue from substance abuse and depression to sleeplessness.

“It can cause developmental lags because all of the resources that children are supposed to put into learning and intelligence and coordination and thinking and being healthy are having to be deferred to survival,” Buffington said.

Clearly, one way to prevent mental trauma would be to stop it from happening in the first place – a heavy task that panelists said is not realistically always possible.

Still, Dr. Glenda Wrenn, director of the Division of Behavioral Health at Morehouse School of Medicine in Atlanta, said increasing attention is being paid to how to treat mental trauma to help patients deal with the traumatic experience itself, not just its effects.

Wrenn, a clinical psychiatrist, noted that while traumatic events can trigger negative adaptive behaviors, it can also spark resiliency. How often people experience trauma, as well as other factors, can impact one’s ability to bounce back, but it is also possible to build resiliency.

“It can be developed and strengthened and enhanced through developing core competencies,” Wrenn told the audience.

Buffington, along with other panelists, also concurred. As people acknowledge their trauma and see possible survival strategies, they can also come to see their strengths to move forward. “Believe it or not there is hope,” she said.

Additional tips and story suggestions from panelists:

  • Too often, news stories covering a violent act mention at the end that the alleged perpetrator had a mental illness (often untreated). That needs to be reported out more and put higher in the stories to show the true effects of mental illness. To put it at the end as an aside normalizes it, and makes it seem like a random act of violence with no root cause.
  • Don’t just highlight bad news. It’s important to report on survivor stories to show how people overcome barriers, including black women.
  • Write about victims of gun violence, especially young black males – often nobody asks them how they feel. Build relationships to get past a victim’s “armor.” Show the true effects violence can have on people and their community.
  • Look at the full impact of trauma on youth and education. Investigate the growing number of “trauma-informed schools.”
  • Don’t stereotype victims or perpetrators. They can be anybody.

One thought on “Mental trauma is everywhere, panelists tell AHCJ members

  1. James Blair

    There are significant hazards in undertaking deep research which includes interviewing victims of tragic events. These threats lurk on both sides of this interactive process. The importance of dealing with potential emotional reactions from all parties can not be overstated. My experience as an Advisor/Mentor to students seeking terminal degrees is personally and professionally gratifying and at times challenging.
    Case in point: The Federal Department Health and Human Services funded a program for a Ph.D. Nursing with a major in Homeland Security. The Research Question: “What were the experiences of providing care to patients during and after Hurricane Katrina, (between August 28, 2005, and September 12, 2005)?”
    Nurse Marti Jordan Ph.D. graduated and wrote a book based on her doctoral work. “Nursing in Hell: The Katrina Experience”
    It is a tragic tale of a group of courageous nurses who braved the horror of treating frail, vulnerable patients, all trapped in disintegrating hospitals.
    The bond that kept the group together was that their story would save nurses from their fate-“so this would never happen again.”
    The closer we got to co-author another book on the serial failures of the healthcare community in New Orleans, Dr. Jordan started distancing herself from the disaster. All the time and care we took to protect the nurses from further emotional harm, we neglected to protect Dr. Jordan from the indirect trauma associated with her research. So “Katrina” picks up one more PTSD victim.

Leave a Reply